Choosing between a finished handmade bag and a set of charms for an existing tote can feel like comparing two different ways to refresh your womens bags collection. You might need a complete bag you can carry today, or you might want to put a personal stamp on the beach tote you already own. Both options live in the womens bags space, but they solve different problems. This head-to-head looks at the Handmade Shoulder Drawstring Cotton Owl Bag and the Charms for Bogg Bag Accessories to help you decide which one fits your next purchase.
Quick verdict: If you want a ready-to-carry handmade bag, choose the Handmade Shoulder Drawstring Cotton Owl Bag. If you already have a rubber beach tote and want to make it yours, go with the Charms for Bogg Bag Accessories.
| Product | Price | Price Bar | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Handmade Shoulder Drawstring Cotton Owl Bag | USD 30.00 | Shoppers who want a ready-to-carry statement bag | |
| Charms for Bogg Bag Accessories | USD 9.99 | Shoppers who want to personalize an existing rubber beach tote |
Where the owl bag wins: It wins for shoppers who need a complete, self-contained bag they can carry immediately. The owl detailing gives it personality, and the dimensions offer practical space for everyday items. If you want a womens bag that doesn't require extra accessories, this is the pick.
Where the charms win: They win for customization. They are the lower-priced pick and attach with a button-style clip to a rubber tote. If you already own a compatible bag and want a quick refresh, these charms are the easier route.
Handmade Shoulder Drawstring Cotton Owl Bag
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
This is the higher-priced choice, and you are paying for a complete, handmade accessory. The quilted cotton body is detailed with embroidered owl accents, and the drawstring closure plus fabric lining give it a polished feel. Its dimensions are roughly 15 inches wide, 14 inches tall, and 3 inches deep, which is enough space for a wallet, phone, and a small book. If you love animal-themed accessories and want something unique, this bag is a strong choice. The limitation is that it is not customizable (Customized: No). For shoppers who want a statement piece, this owl bag is the one.
Charms for Bogg Bag Accessories
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1: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 -->
<!-- skillflare-product-image:v1:eyJwcm9kdWN0X3JlZiI6InNraWxsZmxhcmVfY29uc29sZS5kYXRhX29iamVjdHM6cHJvZHVjdDplYmF5OnJldmlldy1zaXRlOlVTOmVuOmViYXk6Mzc3NDExMjM0MzgwIiwiY2FuZGlkYXRlcyI6W3sicHJvZHVjdF9yZWYiOiJza2lsbGZsYXJlX2NvbnNvbGUuZGF0YV9vYmplY3RzOnByb2R1Y3Q6ZWJheTpyZXZpZXctc2l0ZTpVUzplbjplYmF5OjM3NzQxMTIzNDM4MCIsIm1lZGlhX3JlZiI6InNraWxsZmxhcmVfY29uc29sZS5kYXRhX21lZGlhX2Fzc2V0czpwcm9kdWN0OmViYXk6cmV2aWV3LXNpdGU6VVM6ZW46ZWJheTozNzc0MTEyMzQzODA6MDQ6MDA1NDliZGRmYmE1Iiwic3RvcmFnZV9rZXkiOiJpbWFnZXMvMDYvMDY3MTg0MDQzODFiNDRkNjlmNTc5MDAzNjM4NWJkZDZiZDYzMGFkNzNlN2M0YWNjODY3OGVmZTYzN2JmODMxNC5qcGciLCJ1cmxfa2V5IjoiaW1hZ2VzLzA2LzA2NzE4NDA0MzgxYjQ0ZDY5ZjU3OTAwMzYzODViZGQ2YmQ2MzBhZDczZTdjNGFjYzg2NzhlZmU2MzdiZjgzMTQuanBnIn1dLCJhbHQiOiJDaGFybXMgZm9yIEJvZ2cgQmFnIEFjY2Vzc29yaWVzLCBCb2dnIEJhZyBDaGFybXMgZm9yIEJlYWNoIFRvdGUgUnViYmVyIEJlYWNoIEJhZyJ9 -->
This is the lower-priced choice, and it lets you refresh a rubber beach tote. The set includes button-style clips that are 0.59 inches in diameter, sized to fit the holes in a Bogg bag. The charms themselves are made of high-quality rubber that is reusable, non-toxic, and odorless, so they are suited for beach use. Customer reviews rate them 4.9 out of 5. The limitation is that they are not a bag: they only work if you already own a compatible rubber tote with holes to accept the buttons. If you are looking for a complete womens bag, these charms won't replace one. But if you want to personalize your existing bag, they are a simple add-on.
Final choice by use case: Choose the Handmade Shoulder Drawstring Cotton Owl Bag if you need a ready-to-carry womens bag with personality. Choose the Charms for Bogg Bag Accessories if you already have a rubber beach tote and want to make it stand out. For a bag you can use today, go with the owl bag; for a quick accessory upgrade, the charms are the better fit.
